The Truth About the Dream Life
Following my sister-in-law's "truth in blogging" movement, I have to come clean. Everything is NOT paradise here in the Japan countryside. Its been a very stressful week (and we knew it would be). On Sunday we drove 5 hours to Nagoya where Tomoe's parents live. A full week would be our longest stay at their house ever.
Now, before you get the cliche images of "hell with the in-laws", know that I personally am (for the most part) able to handle them without any stress. Her dad seems to hate silence, so is always trying to find something to talk about even when I just want to sit there quietly, but he has good intentions and I really like him, so I can handle it. Her mom is going through some rough times of her own, increasingly showing signs of alzhimers. She has a peculiar way of expressing herself, complaining about most everything, even if she doesn't have anything against it. I am fine with this, as the negativity is hardly ever aimed at me, but it stresses Tomoe to no end. A stressed Tomoe, of course, leads to a stressed Kevin.
Before Mona was born Tomoe was talking about going to Nagoya for two months before and after the birth. I was very much against it, knowing how she gets when she even spends and hour talking to her mom on the phone. I couldn't even imagine her spending two months with her mom, let alone with a new-born baby. Oh, how right I was.
Tomoe's parents are both in their 70s and taking care of their granddaughter (Tomoe's niece, 9 years old). It adds to the stress to see the niece struggle with life there. Aside from no one to run and play with, dealing with her gradma is tough on her. She is very noticably introverted when grandma is around, due to constant scolding and negtivity, but when Tomoe or I are alone with her, she is active and talkative and smiles a lot.
We have long assumed that one day we will be taking over as her leagal guardians, originally thinking it would be when either Tomoe's mother or father dies, but after this last week I told Tomoe's father that we are ready for/want her anytime/as soon as possible. It stresses me to see her living there amongst the clutter and suppressed life, but there is also the issue of her father, who lives nearby and she stays with on the weekends. If she were to come live with us here, she would be happier in all regards except that her father is so far away. He would also be upset, I think. Then there is the grandma. I am not sure, but it seems that the one thing that keeps her going is taking care of her granddaughter. Given her worsening illness, I wonder what would happen if we were to take the girl away.
Still, I believe that it is in the girl's best interest to get out of the situation, as does her grandfather and Tomoe. What is the best thing to do here? It causes Tomoe stress and causes me sadness. She has her whole life ahead of her, and I want it to be the best it can be, but I don't want to ruin her father or grandmother's hope for living.




Comments
赤ちゃんかわいいですねまだ実際に見ていないので、今度拝見させてくださいね
Posted by: 栄村住人 | April 4, 2010 03:42 PM
Hmmm, difficult situation. I don't know what the deal is with her father, but still he is her father. No one has more say in the matter than he does, legally, morally, and socially. (think about how you would feel if someone else decided to make decisions about Mona). For the niece herself a separation from her father is a much bigger deal than it might seem to you. Even if there are issues children need their parents in ways that go beyond just providing for them. The whole thing with identity and continuity plays a big role in how children see themselves. Part of the problem in Japan is the reduced role that men are asked or expected to play in their children's lives, with even the legal system against them. It could be that the girl's father doesn't feel he has a right to say anything, since here it is the mother who is considered the only really important guardian of the child. I would think that it is just as important to help reinforce the role of the father in the girl's life, both from the father's point of veiw and the girl's.
Posted by: Miguel | April 4, 2010 06:36 PM
Oh Kevin, it is so hard. I know she is only nine, but what does your niece want? Because while it is important to consider everyone, the adults have had their lives, yet your niece has her whole life ahead of her.
Posted by: natalia | April 4, 2010 09:42 PM
@ everyone: I am responding to most of your comments (including those who commented via email) privately.
@ Natalia: She doesn't know what she wants. She loves it here, where we live, but she also loves her dad. The ideal for her would be for her dad to move here to our house and we all live together, but that aint gonna happen.
She is getting older and more mature, so she might be able to see that this is the best option, and if she comes here she is old enough that we can send her back to visit her dad once a month (not as often as she sees him now). It is quite a long train ride, but...
Anyway, I completely agree about her life being priority over the others, but I still feel bad to hurt someone else.
Posted by: kevin | April 4, 2010 11:06 PM
Tough post!
I guess the best would be for her to come and live with you guys. Her father can come see her and take her for weekends here and there.
Interesting comments about your FIL. Mine HATES to talk!! It makes him nervous when he sees me. I am a chatter-box and he doesnt know what to do with me : ). Good thing my Japanese is still limited to 10 words total!
Posted by: weekendfarmer | April 8, 2010 07:27 PM
I'm out of league here. Too much brain power on disaply!
Posted by: Journey | May 11, 2011 12:56 AM